Field Notes · Messaging

69% of buyers caught your website and your sellers telling different stories.

Gartner asked 632 B2B buyers what goes wrong. Most had noticed the website saying one thing and the seller saying another. Before a launch, that gap is the first thing to close.

69%of B2B buyers report inconsistencies between a supplier's website and its sellers
Two halves of a broken ceramic plate laid side by side, their edges not fitting
Two halves that do not fit. Art direction: Fiction Tribe, produced with AI.
· 3 min read

The short version

  • Gartner surveyed 632 B2B buyers. 69% reported inconsistencies between a supplier's website and what its sellers told them.
  • Forrester found 82% of C-level leaders believe their teams are aligned. 65% of the people doing the work say the leaders are not.
  • A launch magnifies whatever story you already tell. Two stories become two louder stories.
  • Fix the document, then the website, then the talk track. In that order.

Marketing says the product saves time. Sales says it cuts risk. The website says something about a platform. Launch is in a quarter, and nobody can agree which sentence the customer should hear first.

The customer has already noticed. In a Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, released in 2025, 69% said they had found inconsistencies between what a sales organisation's website said and what its sellers told them. That is not a rare failure. It is the normal experience of buying from you.

Does a mismatch really cost deals?

It costs trust, and trust is what a B2B deal runs on. Robert Blaisdell, a VP Analyst in Gartner's sales practice, put it plainly: when sellers provide information that does not match the organisation's messaging elsewhere, "it can create mistrust, potentially putting the transaction at risk."

69%
of B2B buyers report inconsistencies between a supplier's website and its sellers. Gartner, survey of 632 B2B buyers, 2025

The same survey found 61% of buyers would prefer a rep-free buying experience. We read that as a warning about order. A buyer who would rather skip the seller has usually read the website before the call. If the two disagree, the seller starts the meeting arguing with a page the buyer has already read.

Why do the two teams tell different stories?

Because each team believes the other one is already aligned. Forrester's 2024 Priorities Survey found 82% of C-level B2B leaders say their product, sales and marketing teams are aligned. Its Q2 2024 alignment survey found 65% of sales and marketing professionals see a lack of alignment between those same leaders. Forrester's summary was blunt: high perceptions of alignment, a low degree of actual alignment.

Your leadership thinks the story is settled. Your buyers have heard two of them.

Hold the limits in view. Both Forrester sample sizes are missing from the public page, and the full report sits behind a client login. The Gartner figures are self-reported by buyers, and the release does not publish the full method. Neither study measured lost revenue. They measured what people noticed and believed. For a launch, that is enough to act on.

How do you get one value proposition before launch?

Write it down once, in a document both teams sign, and make every other surface copy from it. The disconnect usually exists because the value proposition lives in two places: a marketing deck and the heads of the best sellers. Neither is wrong. They are just separate.

1. Collect both versions, word for word. Ask five sellers to record the first two minutes of their pitch. Pull the homepage headline, the launch draft and the product one-pager. Put them in one document, side by side.

2. Ask buyers which one they heard. Call three recent customers. Ask why they bought, and write down their words. The version that matches theirs wins, whoever wrote it.

3. Write one sentence and three proofs. One sentence for what changes for the customer. Three proof points each team can say without a slide. Anything that does not fit gets cut.

4. Fix the website before the talk track. Buyers meet the site first. Update the pages a launch will send traffic to, then hand sellers the same words.

5. Check it a month after launch. Listen to five calls and read the homepage again. If the words have drifted, the document was not the source. Make it the source.

If you want help with that document, our Messaging Platform sprint does this work in two weeks, at a fixed $6,000: a messaging platform and canvas, four to six ideal customer profiles, and a value proposition framework.

A launch does not create a story. It turns up the volume on the one you already have. Make sure there is only one.

Questions people ask

We are preparing a major product launch, but sales and marketing describe our core value proposition completely differently to customers. How do we fix this disconnect before going to market?

Write one value proposition down, test it against what buyers already read on your website, and make sellers use the same words before launch day. Gartner found 69% of B2B buyers notice inconsistencies between a supplier's website and its sellers, and warns that the mismatch creates mistrust. Fix the source document first, then the website, then the talk track.

How common is a mismatch between a company's website and its sales team?

Very common. In a Gartner survey of 632 B2B buyers, released in 2025, 69% reported inconsistencies between the information on a sales organisation's website and what its sellers told them.

Do sales and marketing leaders think they are aligned?

Mostly yes, and their teams mostly disagree. Forrester reported in October 2024 that 82% of C-level B2B professionals say their product, sales and marketing teams are aligned, while 65% of sales and marketing professionals see a lack of alignment between their leaders.

Sources

  1. Gartner Sales Survey Finds 61% of B2B Buyers Prefer a Rep-Free Buying Experience, BizTechReports (Gartner press release), . Republished Gartner release. Survey of 632 B2B buyers; self-reported, full method not on the page.
  2. The Truth About B2B Sales And Marketing Alignment, Forrester, . Analyst blog. Sample sizes for both surveys are not published on the page; the full report is for clients.

Finished work in two weeks, at a fixed price.

A sprint ships a messaging platform, a brand system or a campaign in fourteen days. You see the scope and the number before we start.

See how sprints run

Keep reading

Measurement

Amazon wrote 16 benchmark tips. None says spend less.

Amazon Ads explains how its benchmarks work and what to do about them. On PPC Land's count, not one of the 16 recommended actions tells you to spend less.

· 3 min read
0 of 16Amazon benchmark actions that suggest cutting a budget or pausing a campaign
Positioning

Only 14% of buyers will pay for the difference you think you have.

Research by CEB, Google and Motista found buyers barely tell leading brands apart on business value, and only 14% would pay a premium for the difference. A launch built on features joins the 86%.

· 3 min read
14%of B2B decision makers will pay a premium for a brand's differentiation
Every note